Work & money: Hands off the 401(k)

Matt.Gonzales

January 21, 2009 by Matt.Gonzales

0 votes

The national unemployment rate is at its worst in over a decade. People who never expected to be unemployed — people just like you — are suddenly wondering, “What happened?”

Unfortunately, in a time when the newly jobless need to focus their energy on answering truly pressing questions (like how to pay the mortgage), they have to deal with many they’d never considered. A particularly thorny one: What to do with your 401(k)?

After a couple of months without a regular paycheck, it’ll be tempting to use it to pay the mortgage. But Roy Bodinus, an investment partner with CBG, Inc., says to hold your horses. Anything you take out of your 401(k) will immediately be taxable. And if you’re under 59 and a half years old, it’ll also be subject to an additional 10 percent penalty.

“It should be a last resort,” Bodinus said. And not just because of the tax and penalty.

“People overlook the negative implications of foregoing years and years of compound growth,” Bodinus said. “You don’t get those years back.”

Rather than simply doing nothing, Bodinus suggests rolling that money into an IRA. There are no taxes or penalties, and an IRA has significant advantages over a 401(k).

“You have control over it,” he said. “You aren’t limited to the investment options of your former employer’s 401(k).”

You can reduce how much you pay in fees, too. “A lot of people think they aren’t paying any fees when their assets are sitting in a 401(k),” Bodinus said. “But they are paying an internal expense ratio. Big companies like Merrill Lynch aren’t nonprofits. It’s painless, because you don’t see it, but it’s happening.”

Expense ratios are unavoidable. But with an IRA through an investment management company (Bodinus suggests Vanguard), you often pay significantly less.

Say you roll your 401(k) into an IRA. When you return to the workforce, you’ll likely have the chance to roll that cash into your new employer’s 401(k). Bodinus’ advice? Don’t do it.

“I don’t see many advantages to it. Again, you’re limited to the investment options of your employer.”

Some argue a 401(k) is preferable because it has a loan provision. But Bodinus advises against borrowing against your retirement plan. “There are two reasons not to: the negative tax implications, and it takes away from compound growth.”

Instead, he recommends always having four to six months worth of expenses in a cash reserve account. Because in times like these, you just never know.

Forum: Work & money

Tags: 

work, jobs, unemployment, 401(k), IRA, loans

Follow this thread

5 comments

Zombieguy
Zombieguy, January 21, 2009
0 votes

Everyone recommends having 6 months worth of expenses in saving, but really how many 20/30 somethings actually do?

Sparkman
Sparkman, January 22, 2009
0 votes

Mr. Bodinus offers some misleading information regarding fees for investments in 401(k) plans vs. IRAs. While his advice about not taking funds out of your 401(k) if you are laid off is sound, putting it into an IRA may not always be the best chooice. In many cases, the investment fees for options in a 401(k) are less than for retail funds purchased through an IRA because they are “institutionally priced” funds which the employer can select because of the sizeable assets in the plan vs. an individual account. While Vanguard funds have among the lowest investment expense ratios for their retail funds, many of the same funds are offered in 401(k) plans with even lower expense ratios. So, in some cases, employees may be better off leaving their money in the 401(k) if they are happy with the fund selection. Also, if the IRA is set up through an investment adviser (rather than directly with the fund company), the adviser will have to be compensated in some way — often through an asset-based fee which comes out of the investment option.

A second point. Merrill Lynch does not offer its own investments any more since they sold that portion of their business to Blackrock. They do record keeping and administration for retirement plans providing empoloyers with the option to select from a wide variety of options from various investment firms.

rictor
rictor, January 22, 2009
0 votes

5961/27 years old?

Ben Neff
Ben Neff, January 22, 2009
0 votes

Thanks for the catch. Fixed.

JohnScott
JohnScott, January 23, 2009
0 votes

I cashed out some of my 401k when I was in my 20s and I really regret it. Do not cash out people.

or register to leave a comment.

Logo_colophon

© 2010 Star Media
All rights reserved.

Use of this site signifies your agreement to the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy, updated December 2008.