Local Mexican Restaurants
Good Mexican food is a scarcity in this burg. Things have improved with the influx of Mexican-born people here over the past several years. Now there are a few more places where you can get authentic cuisine, even the stuff I don't eat like tongue tacos and brains. (Yeah, I didn't eat that stuff before I was a vegetarian.)
So here's my list of favorite Mexican restaurants in Indy. Please feel free to leave comments and add to it. Guess that's kinda the point of a blog, huh?
Formerly #1: El Sol (R.I.P.) there was one on E. Washington St. west of Irvington and another at Union Station - BEST MEXICAN FOOD EVER. But they never had many customers. Granted you'd feel like you ate two bowls of Super Colon Blow after dining but it was so worth it. They had these corn cakes with some kind of spicy red chili sauce (so flavorful), refried beans and queso blanco oh. my. gawd.
Currently #1. El Jaripeo on E. Washington St. near Movies 8 - I love this place but have only been there maybe three times since it's kinda far from my neck o' the woods. But I've loved everything I ordered there. Best margaritas in town and some bomb-ass shrimp quesadillas, with sauce on them! Quesadillas with sauce! No dry, crunchy tortillas.
Two: Cancun - This place is pretty awesome. Good food, good service and resonable prices. If you can stand the lame latin pop piped in while dining, you'll be glad you went. This place is family owned and operated. My favorites are the Enchiladas del Mar (seafood enchiladas, ok so I'm a pesce-vegetarian) and the Sopapillas. They also have a really good chicken dish called Pollo Sabroso with a sauce that is criminally delicious. I used to order it when I was a carnivore.
No tongue tacos or brains though, I'm afraid. There are two locations that I know of, one on 65th and Keystone, near Kroger and one in Carmel somewhere (or is it Fishers?) There's also Jose Frog's on the south side (owned by the same people).
Three: La Hacienda on E. Washington St. - nothing adventurous, just good traditional Mexican fare at cheap prices. And the restaurant is in this really weird lime green building that looks like some little kid's idea of a space station circa 1956.
Four: La Jolla on Broad Ripple Avenue - good food but a little overpriced. They also have really good margaritas. Their seafood enchiladas aren't on par with Cancun's but still worth eating.
Five: The Mexican place in Fountain Square that took approximately two years to finally open up and will probably do better business once they obtain their liquor license - Unfortunately I can't remember the name of this place. But the food's cheap and good so it's worth visiting, unless you're in the mood for drinks other than those manufactured by Coca Cola. I like their spinach enchiladas and their cheese ones are pretty good too. did I mention it's cheap? I ordered two cheese enchiladas and a side of rice once and paid less than five bucks. That's, like, Taco Bell cheap.
(I switched from numerals to written out numbers 'cause there's something hinky with my numbered list. I'm not trying to be fancy.)
If you're a fan of Cancun, there is also one on E 82nd a little east of Castleton Square. Cazuelas (there's a chance I spelled that correctly) near Michigan & 86th is also part of the Cancun/Jose Frog family.
"Three: La Hacienda on E. Washington St. - nothing adventurous, just good traditional Mexican fare at cheap prices. And the restaurant is in this really weird lime green building that looks like some little kid's idea of a space station circa 1956."
I've lived on the east side for most of my life... and I seem to recall it being a KFC, before they were called KFC... and it was painted up with the red and white panels to look like a bucket of the Colonel's chicken... maybe it some kind of odd dream.
BTW, it's one of my favorite "cheap Mexican" restaurants around Indy.
There's another La Hacienda at Graham and Binford on the Northeast side ... I assume they're related and since I live nearby to that one, I can heartily agree that it's yummy basic Mexican food.
Jolene@foodiemom.com : RE: Local Mexican Restaurants More..
Try the Mexican baked goods at Merry's Bakery, 4107 W. Michigan St. Breads, cakes, cookies, sweet rolls -- it's all good. Pick up a tray and tongs and serve yourself from the cases then take your selections to the register to pay.
Our La Haciendawe eat there prob 2-3 times a month. It is like 5 mins from the house. We also love Cancun (formerly Cazuella's) near 86th and Michigan... they have great seviche.
lisa_citymouse : RE: Local Mexican Restaurants More..
Ooh, I've definitely got to visit them. Thanks!
lisa_citymouse : RE: Local Mexican Restaurants More..
Yeah. I'd probably eat there 3 or 4 times a month, too if I lived closer to it. I normally only go there when I'm visiting my Irvington friends.
Cancun's seviche is da bomb. (Hee. I tickle myself when I use outdated hip-hop slang, yo.)
Pancho's Taqueria is located just south of 71st on Michigan Rd. It is an authentic taqueria that has outstanding guacamole, a salsa bar, and cheap, quick, awesome food. Their steak tacos are yummy and you can dress them up with pico de gallo, cilantro, cabbage, lime, and your choice of 6 or so different salsas, all from the salsa bar. This is a place where you order at the counter and then they call your number when the food is done. Frequented by mexican folk, which gives it the seal of approval in my book. You can get beer there, but no mixed drinks, so don't expect to go there and tank up on margheritas! My family and I eat there fairly regularly - it is worth the drive from Meridian Kessler area. Pancho also opened another restaurant in Fisher's (96th and Allisonville).
La Piedad is pretty good, but their guacamole is not near as good as Pancho's.
El Sol is overpriced, in my opinion.
I'm with Kimiko. Once you go to one of those taquerias where you have dig back in your brain archives for your old high school Spanish-speaking skills, there's no turning back. Believe me, I've tried. It's hard to beat real tacos on soft corn tortillas with shredded (not ground) meat and cilantro and lime on the side -- all this and better taste for the same price or less than the price of Taco Bell item that pales in comparison. And then there's sopes, pupusas, empanadas, huaraches...all amazingly delicious. Folks, these places will turn Cancun, El Rodeo, Taco Bell, Chi Chis into a faded, bland memory. Okay, Jayro. Where can I get these wonderful things? Here's a couple good spots: Guatelinda (formerly La Guanaquita), 3107 Lafayette Road. - this place has a nice mix of Mexican and El Salvadorean food items, like pupusas, sopes and empanadas, along with standard taqueria fare. Good service, twice as good food. Pancho's Taqueria, 7023 N. Michigan Road A lot of the foodies dig this place. Great selection of authentic entrees, good service and the wonderful hot salsa bar. Give 'em a shot and see what you think.
...and don't be afraid to try the lengua (beef tongue)! It just tastes like really good pot roast.
kimikokopuffs : RE: Local Mexican Restaurants More..
I have to agree. I have eaten lengua. Not by choice, though. On principal, it weirds me out. But I didn't know what it was and it was DELICIOUS.
lisa_citymouse : RE: Local Mexican Restaurants More..
Back in my carnivorous days, I loved pot roast so I would've been all about lengua, if I could've gotten over the fact that I was eating beef tongue. I was never a big fan of organ meats.
I love me some empanadas, though.



32 comments