I think Jason Castro was there because he was cute and girls were voting to keep him there for his model good looks. I personally think he was smoking a big fatty before each show haha. David Archuletta, I agree, he's on his way to Disney. I completely picture him in High School Musical 4 or some crap. He's not my thing at all! Every year there are a handful that make me wonder what people are thinking. I knew Taylor Hicks would fall flat and he did. The only reason he did so good was because he's a great live performer. But, once they are off the show, it's about record sales. People need to close their eyes and just listen to their voices after a few shows. You'll see Simon sitting there with his eyes closed, or his eyes off to the side. He's listening to their voice. He knows that it's all about the voice and what's on the radio. If you like the song on the radio then you'll go see them in concert and watch their video, but for the most part you are listening to them. I really liked Carly from her audition and thought she would be in the final two anyway but her song choices sucked. After about two major shows with David Cook, I was hooked! Carly slowly fell off my favorite list and David Cook became my favorite, especially after Billy Jean, wow. He's amazing!

I don't get reality TV in general.

It must be a chick thing.

I agree. I think David Cook has major potential!

I like reality TV, not American Idol but a lot of the other stuff.