Today:
Posted: Feb 09, 2008 in Music
Tags:
As the "2 Worlds 2 Voices" co-star with 31 years of recording on her resume, Reba McEntire brought several things to Conseco Fieldhouse Friday night.
Beyond a wealth of story songs and a knack for professional entertainment, country music's McEntire provided an opportunity for pop music's Kelly Clarkson to shine.
Clarkson, still six years shy of her 31st birthday, repeatedly brought down the house during the duo's performance -- one of just 15 dates on a smartly produced tour.
In a stress-free setting of shared songs and shared responsibilities, the original "American Idol" delivered one of the best vocal performances in the basketball arena's nine-year history.
Clarkson first wowed the estimated audience of 10,000 when she added sky-scraping runs to "Why Haven't I Heard from You?" -- a slice of honky-tonk bliss that arrived second on the program.
While acrobatic stunt vocals are a lowlight of "Idol's" legacy, Clarkson's range and resilience are too mighty to dismiss.
McEntire's voice is no liability, as evidenced by more than 50 million albums sold. But a waver and a helium tone become defining characteristics when placed in contrast to Clarkson for two hours.
The younger artist sounded ferocious during "Miss Independent," which careened far from Nashville when featuring a guitar quote of Black Sabbath's "Iron Man."
Clarkson's tone was full and robust on "The Greatest Man I Never Knew," McEntire's emotional tribute to her father.
And fans in the first 20 rows fanned their arms in "we're not worthy" reverence of Clarkson when she sang Patty Griffin's gospel-tinged "Up to the Mountain."
Thirteen backing musicians gave the show an equation of powerful singing plus powerful instrumentation. The players were equally adept at twang and soul, most notably when steel guitar and fiddle added accents to Clarkson's "Beautiful Disaster."
McEntire, dressed in blue jeans and a sleeveless top to match Clarkson's wardrobe, did her best work during a version of 1993 hit "Does He Love You?"
She and Clarkson portrayed a wife and a mistress who traded lines to transform a duet into a duel.
The "2 Worlds 2 Voices" tour seems to be succeeding in distancing Clarkson from last year's true-life verbal sparring with record label executive Clive Davis.
Her voice has far more staying power than that particular inside-the-industry squabble.
As a person that went to the concert I really have to disagree with you. I do like Kelly Clarkson but there is one thing that sets Reba McIntire apart from the rest and that is her great voice. You say helium and that's craziness really and the record sells prove it. Even though I like Kelly and have her albums you have to realize that being with Reba is really an honor. Reba's voice is one of a kind!! You can never manufacture that type of style. I think you really need to check your ears because looking at the whole picture comparing those two together as equals you have to be kidding me. Reba made it the hard way and Kelly came from a show that made her who she is by the industry not original at all. The are both great singers but seriously I guess you really don't like country music because without women like Reba and her unique voice many may have never been given a chance to be heard.
As a person that went to the concert I really have to disagree with you. ...
I really disagree with your comment. I'm sorry but McEntire's voice is nowhere near as great as Kelly's. I went to the concert as well sat in the third row. I believe Kelly's voice overpowered Reba's! I love them both but Kelly stole the show that night with her voice.
I think that this concert was one of the best concerts I have ever been to. Kelly and Reba rocked the house together and I loved that they stayed out together the whole time. I think they compliment each other and their energy was awesome. I also met them before the show and WOW. They were so down to earth and friendly. Good times!
This was one of the best concerts I've ever been to, and I was honestly very skeptical. I agree with Tara's comments...Reba and Kelly were so respectful to each other and you could tell that they enjoy performing together. I think it means a lot for an American Idol star to have such profound respect for a legend like Reba! I really liked that they stayed on stage together the entire concert, and that even when singing backup, they both looked like they were having a great time.
I love Reba, but I had the most fun dancing and singing along during Kelly's songs. I honestly can't say a negative thing about the entire concert. Even the opening comedian was entertaining.