Honestly, i agree with you on a lot of ideas that you present. However, i disagree with you on one thing. The camparisons are going to be made, but they should not be made. Petyon is himself and his brother Eli is a different person. They also play on different styles of foot ball teams. So i think its totally not fair to compare the two. Its like comparing two different variables in science, its not very productive.

hey did you guys hear the news... Eli Manning sucks!

thanks for the newsflash walter cronkite

how does eli manning suck?? i dont get it.. he just beat the Patriots on a game winning drive.. i honestly think he is pretty good

you're right azelikovich. Eli is pretty good... at sucking! sorry, just a personal vendetta against the most classless, overrated player in the NFL. he's a mediocre player with a Hall-of-Fame name.

yeah you are right, i guess. Peyton has had to carry a greater load as everyone knows the Indy's defense was not very good in Peytons early years. As well if the Giants Defense didnt SMOTHER and i mean SMOTHER the Patriots than Eli would not have even had a chance. so i guess im wrong and eli is not that good.

Why is every going against Eli Manning. If i am not mistaken, he has just won a super bowl (XLII) and was named MVP of the super bowl. This is an accomplishment that Dan Marino had never achieved. To win a super bowl you have to be a good quarterback.