Today:
Those who expect an all-Russian orchestra concert to be as heavy as an overly rich meal should think again -- at least in terms of this weekend's Indianapolis Symphony Orchestra program.
Nuance and subtlety stand out in the current ISO weekender, featuring the local debut of the extraordinary pianist Yundi Li, along with guest conductor Andrew Litton's program of 19th- and 20th-century Russian fare.
Of Sergei Prokofiev's five piano concertos, No. 3 in C Major is probably the most popular. My first memorable experience with it was Russian pianist Bella Davidovich's interpretation, which stood out for its power.
On Friday night at Hilbert Circle Theatre, Li gave an interpretation of Prokofiev's Piano Concerto No. 2 in G minor that was sublime for altogether different reasons. The Chinese-born pianist, who made a name for himself on the competition circuit a few years ago, is among those rare interpreters who can make poetry of Prokofiev, even during some of his most percussive moments.
Li's lyrical concept of the concerto became clear early, just a few bars after the orchestra lit into the staccato, clarinet-studded opening. The pianist's entry, underscored by violins, was hypnotically beautiful. Later in that same "Andantino" movement, during the long solo cadenza, Li eloquently brought out a single-note melody from a flurry of fast notes.
During the "Scherzo," a perpetual motion reminiscent of "The Flight of the Bumblebee," Li again maintained control. Even amid bossy interjections from the brass in the "Intermezzo," Li held steady with melodic grace.
Nearly the entire audience gave Li an immediate standing ovation, applauding away until he returned again and again, finally with an encore, a Liszt waltz.
Litton, the former longtime Dallas Symphony Orchestra music director, is a stocky conductor with a flair for a muscular, yet generally controlled orchestral sound. The ISO's opening "War and Peace" Overture, again by Prokofiev, was fairly heavy-handed, as were the opening and final movements of the Tchaikovsky Fourth Symphony, which followed intermission.
Then again, Tchaikovsky's "Andantino" second movement was utterly relaxed, featuring Roger Roe's oboe theme elegantly echoed by a number of other sections and soloists. And the "Scherzo," with its pizzicatos bouncing back and forth between high and low strings, could not have been lighter or brighter.
I went to Yundi Li's Friday night performance of Prokofiev's 2nd piano concerto. I must say that I totally disagree with this reviewer's opinion of this performance. Mr. Li missed so many notes in the first movement that I have to wonder at what point is it no longer Prokofiev? The third movement was played, in my opinion, much too fast. Mr. Li seemed stiff and uncomfortable during the entire performance and this translated into an uninspiring experience as an audience member. No doubt that this is a difficult composition. I would advise Mr. Li to stop performing this piece live for a while and practice it privately to become comfortable with it. Mr. Li is obviously an excellent pianist. But, a good reputation does not translate, in this case, to a good performance. It sounded more like a bad rehersal, not a concert-ready performance. For a quality performance of this piano concerto I recommend listening to Volodos or Lugansky--even Y. Wang plays this better.
The criticism given above is just one of those very unconvincing negative comments you read occasionally. One should realize that the Prokofiev concerto recorded in the CD by DG was taken live from the concert hall in Berlin last year, and Li had played it without a single wrong note. Since then, Li had performed it again and again in quite a few concert halls including the concert hall in Hong Kong. Very good reviews had been given by all the reviewers who had attended these performances. Go to the website Youtube to view this particular performance in Hong Kong concert hall and see if you can find any wrong note. Why should Li had performed badly only in this particular concert attended by the person here?