Today:
In every profession, there is a defining moment. Our founding fathers had to choose between the Declaration of Independence and treason. Lincoln had to decide between preserving the Union and engaging in a vicious Civil War. President John F. Kennedy had to confront the fears of many that the dictates of the Pope in Rome would circumvent our Constitution.
In my case as a menial movie reviewer, I have reached one of those moments, namely whether to be honest in reviewing "Walk Hard: The Dewey Cox Story". Having decided to be forthright at the risk of whatever is left of my reputation, let me say that this hodgepodge faux-biopic is frequently laugh-out-loud hysterical. While anyone with genteel taste will be offended from the very beginning, this movie is devilishly, profanely irreverent from beginning to end.
On one level, this movie is quite effective as a parody of the recent Joaquin Phoenix/Reese Witherspoon film "Walk the Line" and Jamie Foxx's "Ray". Taking no prisoners, instead of a young Johnny Cash accidentally allowing his brother to drown, young Dewey cuts his more talented older brother in half in a machete duel when they were both under the age of 10. Screamingly ludicrous, it also was hysterically funny and set the tone of this movie.
From then on, the movie follows Dewey's rise to stardom in the same manner as was done with Cash and Charles. First comes marriage and children; then unexpected national fame; thereafter comes the descent into drug abuse, philandering and jail.
However, what is surprising is despite the fact that this movie is a parody of the other two, it still is surprisingly moving at times. Well meaning, stupid and incredibly naive, you can't help but root for Dewey to succeed.
More importantly, John C. Reilly nails the part of Dewey, and this makes the film. No matter how preposterous the scene, Reilly saves this picture from devolving into a series of meaningless sketches.
For example, there is a wicked reoccurring scene involving his drummer, wonderfully played by Tim Meadows. Dewey continually walks in on him as he is engaged in the use of drugs with beautiful women in backstage bathrooms. As Dewey inquires as to what is going on, Meadows, trying to dissuade Dewey from participating, farcically describes the drugs in a manner that no one could resist. And it is giving nothing away to say that Dewey can't either.
Another truly inventive scene involves Dewey's experimentation with transcendental meditation in India. In the presence of a Maharishi, he proceeds to drop acid with the Beatles. The banter between them is as inventive as it is funny, and watching the Beatles devolve into a fistfight between John and Paul (played, believe it or not, by Jack Black) is a sight almost impossible to adequately describe.
Furthermore, this movie contains some outstanding music, as bawdy as it is. In particular, during Dewey's stoner protest years in the 1960's, he takes up the cause of midgets in a song that literally leaves the audience in stitches. I'll go out on a limb and say that even if you find the rest of the movie far too silly and profane to enjoy, it is worth seeing for that one song alone.
Clearly, this movie has all but collapsed at the box office. In doing so, I can't help but believe that it was released at the wrong time. It should have appeared in the theaters either before or after the equally raunchy "Superbad". I just think that audiences during the holiday season didn't have time to spend on a dicey movie experience like "Dewey".
In the end, I certainly don't want to suggest that this movie doesn't needlessly go over the top at times. The raunchy scenes of full frontal nudity of men and women while Dewey is in his "orgy phase" was better left on the cutting room floor. Nonetheless, if you are looking for a picture that is guaranteed to make you continually laugh despite the fact that you occasionally hate yourself for doing so, then drop your skepticism and see "Dewey" before it soon disappears from the theater.
Where did my comment go?
irratebass: http://www.indy.com/posts/356
We had a pretty severe server issue that (should be) fully cleared by now.
I personally thought this movie was the biggest piece of garbage I've ever seen in a theater... and I even saw Captain Ron in the theaters!!! haha
Mvittorio:
Didn't I open my review with the statement that "Anyone with gentile taste would be offended from the very beginning"? And by the way, even I couldn't bring myself to see "Captain Ron"! And I usually can find some form of entertainment during a root canal!
http://www.indy.com/posts/2945
I am a big fan of that type of humor, and I don't get huffy with toilet humor or phallic jokes (if they're done right), but I was really disappointed by "Walk Hard." The Beatles segment was not half as funny as I expected with the kind of talent they had, and too many of the jokes fell down.
Joe:
After I left "Walk Hard" I must confess that I felt somewhat unclean as I contemplated my review. I kept trying to convince myself that what I had just seen was nothing more than sophomoric comedic trash. More importantly, I would likely be ridiculed for saying anything to the contrary.
But, alas, I failed in my argument with myself. For all of its shortcomings, I, (along with most of the small audience) repeatedly laughed out loud. Furthermore, for all of its in-your-face humor, there was a surprising subtlety to its parody of "Ray" and "Walk the Line" that I could not help but slightly admire.
More to the point, I have never claimed to be much more than a slightly well informed amateur when it comes to reviewing movies. The movie theater itself has always been a type of sanctuary for me, and I admittedly have a low threshold for entertainment. It takes a pretty God-awful movie for me not to find some type of redeeming value in it. (Good grief, it sounds as if I have morphed into a local version of Pete "I like everything" Hammond of Maxim!)
I was kind of in the middle on this one -- call it two stars out of four. When the movie's on, it's hilarious. But there are loooong stretches in between those moments.
I laughed hardest during the segment where Dewey was singing like Bob Dylan, both the voice and the lyrics, because they were taking a poke at a sacred cow that I think is well-deserving of it.
If the movie had been 45 minutes long (that is, if it had stopped at the 45-minute mark or so), I'd be proclaiming it one of the funniest movies of the year. There were a LOT of laugh-out-loud moments, even LOL-Uncontrollably moments. But they just stopped at some point, and the comedy stopped being funny. The "Let's Duet" sequence was hilarious, I thought (and a great parody song), and the male nudity was awfully funny in a totally gratuitously inappropriate sort of way, but somehow the jokes just ran dry for me and I stopped laughing. I even found myself forcing myself to laugh at the lame jokes.
As much as anything, the movie recycled its own jokes too much. The first machete-body-severing scene I didn't think was funny, but I would have overlooked it had they not pulled it back out later. I did like Tim Meadows' "You don't want none of this s---!" jokes.
Chris, I think I gave it two stars (on the indy.com 5-star scale), mostly because I was so disappointed at how ponderous and unfunny it got down the line.
Chris:
Quite frankly, "Walk Hard" is just to blasted hysterical when it is good not to like. The only way I can think to honestly review it is to use the terms employed by David Alan Grier and Damon Wayans on the old "In Living Color" TV series.
Remember them? Playing two flamboyantly gay movie reviewers, whenever they critiqued a movie they absolutely loved, they gave it "two snaps and an around the world!" Accordingly, let's just give "Walk Hard" "two snaps!"
I agree concerning your description of Dewey's Bob Dylan - like impersonation. In particular, the protest song supporting the plight of midgets was priceless.
Furthermore, Dylan has become a bit of a sacred cow. Quite frankly, that was one of the reasons I found Todd Haynes' "I'm Not There" to be a bit pretentious. Dylan without a guitar is absolutely boring, and so was that film whenever Cate Blanchett is not on the screen.
Chris: Quite frankly, "Walk Hard" is just to blasted hysterical when it is good not ...
Haven't seen this movie, but I do remember 'Men on Films' on 'In Living Color.' Three words.. fab-you-lus!
Here's a video to take you down memory lane: Men on Films on YouTube