posts

I'm Not There

Robert  Hammerle
by Robert Hammerle

Log In to rate this post

(0 Results)

I've always had a theory as to why most critics uniformly waxed eloquent whenever the late Ingmar Bergman would release a new film. Despite the fact that most of his works were so completely droll as to redefine the word tedious, I'm convinced critics stumbled over themselves to praise his films for fear of being perceived as lowbrow or pedestrian.

Thus, at the clear risk of putting myself in the pedestrian category, let me say that with the exception of several incredible performances, Todd Haynes's I'm Not There made me largely wish I wasn't either. While I certainly admire Mr. Haynes's boldness in using six different actors to create an impressionistic work of art centered around the life of the legendary Bob Dylan, the story was so fragmented that it left me far more frustrated than stimulated or entertained.

Haynes's faux documentary of Dylan comes off particularly lacking when compared to Julie Taymor's far more compelling Across the Universe. While both movies were told against the backdrop of the 1960's, with particular emphasis on the Vietnam War, Taymor's movie lit a fuse where Haynes simply could not keep his cinematic wick lit.

Quite frankly, I think the problem is not so much Haynes's innovative approach to his subject as the subject itself. Even though Dylan is played by six different actors, none of them using the name Bob Dylan, you come off with the feeling that, despite his musical genius, Dylan as a person is incredibly dull and largely uninteresting. I couldn't shake the feeling that a particularly unnerving version of Dante's seventh rung of hell would be one long dinner party where you had to sit next to Dylan for an eternity!

But in the end I must say that this movie was saved by several excellent performances, particularly that of Cate Blanchett. Her physical transformation into Dylan at his loopiest was stunning in every sense of the word. While Heath Ledger and Christian Bale make the most out of the little they were called upon to do, Ms. Blanchett's performance will in all probability be remembered at Oscar time. As if she wasn't recognized at the highest level of her craft already, this performance alone would make her legendary.

Those of us who came of age in the 60's remember quite well the many stoners who chemically alienated themselves from reality while using the word "man" in almost every sentence. Conversations repeatedly contained responses such as "How ya doin, man"; or "Hey man, what's up?"; or "Man, that's insane, man."

They were the precursors to today's vapid "Valley Girls" who have found a similar use for the word "like." No one could ever deny that Dylan has produced a greater body of work than any contemporary musician. Unfortunately, once the music is turned off, he's just, like, another trippin'stoner, man.

Follow this thread (RSS)

Christopher Lloyd

I think pack mentality definitely plays a role in critics' opinion. The auteur theory was a very powerful force through the '60s and '70s, and remains the cornerstone of a lot of observers' thinking today.

The way it tends to manifest itself is along the lines of, "Robert Altman is a Great director. Therefore anything he makes is great." Nevermind that his career was a wasteland during the 1980s, and even after his post-"Player" revival had widely uneven moments. Go watch "Ready to Wear," if you can stomach it.

Take Spike Lee. He's an important filmmaker who's made a number of good films and two certifiably great ones ("Malcolm X" and "Do the Right Thing"). But he's also made stuff like "Girl 6" and "Clockers" that is, in a word, unwatchable.

I think people, particularly intellectual urban types parodied by Woody Allen, really got into Bergman because he was making movies that explored really deep topics that people just didn't think film was capable of tackling. Although his stuff certainly is worthy of being parodied, as I discovered after taking a college class on him. I would mentally write the characters' unspoken monologue for them: "I kneel down here in medium shot while I stare up at a 20-degree angle in tortured contemplation of the remoteness of God."

Anyway, I'm rambling. Good post, Robert.

Christopher Lloyd on Nov 26, '07 at 04:16 PM
Robert  Hammerle

Chris:

First of all, thanks for your comments. Secondly, I don't want to come off as an individual who expects every movie to be the functional equivalent of Transformers. (On the other hand, that was a surprisingly good movie!)

Your observations concerning Robert Altman, Spike Lee and Woody Allen are right on point. The truth of the matter is that every good director has had an occasional misfire. While Ang Lee had his Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon and Brokeback Mountain, he also had the imminently forgettable The Hulk. No director, no matter what his or her reputation may be, is above critical analysis.

For example, while Spike Lee often speaks eloquently about the problems facing the African American Community, he nonetheless emulated the worse stereotypes of that culture's male behavior with the way he portrayed women in the Inside Man. Remember how Jody Foster was dressed in her tight business suit and three inch heels, or the fact that Denzel Washington's girlfriend spent the entire movie in heat?

I love the Coen Brothers, but even they have their Ladykillers and Hudsucker Proxy.

Best wishes,

Bob

Robert Hammerle on Nov 28, '07 at 10:32 AM
Matt.Gonzales

I loved Hudsucker Proxy. Maybe it's because I'm from Muncie.

And I don't think Lee emulated the worse stereotypes of black male culture in "Inside Man" (which I also loved). Are all of the directors of schlocky made-for-cable soft porn movies also emulating the worse stereotypes of black male culture?

I think Lee emulated the worse stereotypes of male culture, if anything.

Matt.Gonzales on Nov 28, '07 at 11:52 AM
joe.shearer

I am a fan of the Hudsucker Proxy as well (and have heckuva soft spot for The Ladykillers too), and I'm not from Muncie. :)

joe.shearer on Nov 28, '07 at 02:44 PM
Log In or register to leave a comment

A better job awaits

Enter occupation keywords:
Flash appears here