Header_posts

A word of advice for the local arts community

Matt Gonzales
by Matt Gonzales

Posted: Nov 20, 2007 in Culture

Tags: politics, Indianapolis, arts, Ballard, peterson, chicken little

Log In to rate this post

(0 Results)

Friends in the local arts community, a little friendly advice:

Relax a little, would you?

Yes, Mayor Bart Peterson ("a dear friend of the arts," as some of you have recently called him) is on the way out. But there's no reason to reflexively assume that just because he's a former Marine (gasp!) and a Republican (double gasp!), Greg Ballard just isn't hard-wired to understand or appreciate the nuances of how important a vibrant arts community is to our city.

Now a little healthy skepticism on our part is, well, healthy. But the way some of you are reacting, you'd think Ann Coulter had just been elected mayor.

Yes, Ballard called the arts "unessential spending." I know that has you kind of freaked out. Fair enough. That kind of talk stings. But remember that in the end, that's all it is -- talk. We all know how wide is the sea that divides a politician's words and his actions.

Look on the bright side: When Bart Peterson took office, he wasn't exactly a scholar of the arts; it wasn't his love of Shakespeare or his ardor for Schubert that urged him to help art organizations flourish in Indianapolis. Peterson was just embracing the kind of trendy thinking popularized by economist and author Richard Florida.

Florida's thinking, in a nutshell, goes like this: For a city to thrive in the 21st century, it has to become attractive to Gen-Xers who want more than just safe streets and clean drinking water. They also want a killer music scene, spacious bike paths and theater on the streets. Florida struck a chord with a lot of early 2000-era city leaders, and it's easy to see why: His theory suggested a city can pump money into the arts while growing the economy and attracting bright tech-minded workers. Brilliant!

Unfortunately, it's a lot more complicated than that. Why? Because for better or worse, not all -- dare I say, not even close to a majority -- of the people in Indy care about the arts.

As long as we keep talking like the arts community deserves special treatment, the more we're going to come off like sanctimonious, self-righteous snobs.

The sad fact is, Indianapolis can survive without us. So instead of whining, it would behoove us to start quietly engaging in the kind of grass-roots work that makes the best of us great in the first place.

Instead of crying foul about Ballard maybe cutting funds for the arts before he's even taken office, why not instead impress him by exhibiting qualities you suspect an ex-Marine like him probably admires: Dignity, dedication and a never-say-die attitude?

Since the end of www.intakeweekly.com meant the end of an online home for my weekly column, Circular Logic (which appears in the print version of INtake), I will be posting it here at Indy.com each week. Offended, bored and irritated parties can post their grievances in the comment box.

Follow this thread (RSS)

TJ_Reynolds

I don't know where the freaking out has been, but if Ballard doesn't see the arts as essential to the growth of our economy, as Peterson did, things will get slightly harder. But I ain't scared.

TJ_Reynolds on Nov 20, '07 at 07:32 PM
whitney smith

Nobody can deny that Mayor Peterson helped establish the arts as a priority in Indianapolis during his tenure. But that's not to say that he sparked huge increases in arts funding or promoted particular art forms, except possibly for public visual art.

And Ballard may well establish a cultural agenda of his own.

After Ronald Reagan was first elected President and began pushing to cut the National Endowment for the Arts budget, some feared that arts groups nationally would suffer. Reagan probably didn't do arts groups any favors with the funding cuts, but he wanted to shift more responsibility to states, businesses, foundations and individuals. That happened, and as long as the economy has done well, the model has worked, and there are many more arts groups than there used to be.

whitney smith on Nov 30, '07 at 12:39 PM
Nathaniel_Hood

"The sad fact is, Indianapolis can survive without [arts]."

True, and it will "survive."

I could go without food for a couple days and I would survive, but I would be much worse off. By voting for Ballard, Indianapolisites hammered there out art's coffin.

(sorry i don't think i wrote that well enough)

Nathaniel_Hood on Dec 04, '07 at 02:35 AM
David Lindquist

The mayor gave a nod to the arts at this week's Indy Jazz Fest announcement.

During the news conference, Ballard quoted President Kennedy's belief that arts are "a test of a nation's civilization."

Afterward, he said events such as Indy Jazz Fest attract tourists, companies and their employees to the city.

"Anybody who doesn't think the arts are an asset isn't on the same page with me," Ballard said.

Read more here.

David Lindquist on Feb 09, '08 at 01:34 AM
Log In or register to leave a comment
Flash appears here