Today:
Posted: Oct 31, 2007 in Things to do, Culture, Movies, TV and Celebrities
Tags:
Okay, so I was talking with some people about my thoughts on Jerry Seinfeld's "Bee Movie" (which I can't offically review until Friday, so you'll have to infer my thoughts on it from this thread until then).
Anyway, the conversation turned to whether movies have to always have a message. I argued (and have been for years) that a movie is never "just a movie." Film, like any medium, is in some way a reflection of society and by its nature must in some way espouse the beliefs and ideals of the culture it's made in.
For example, in virtually all American films there is a protagonist (a hero) who we in some way connect with. We are rooting for this person and in some way they represent good (i.e. something our culture or society believes is good).
There is also some force of evil, or something that runs counter to our hero's way of seeing things, or it runs counter to what the protagonist is trying to do.
And in animated films especially there is a message of some sort. In Shrek, among the messages are staying true to yourself and being who you are. In The Incredibles it was the importance of teamwork and family and working together to solve problems. In Toy Story, sharing and teamwork, and so on and so on.
When I discuss this, I am often told "oh, really, come on. It's just a movie. Don't read into it." But that's exactly what a moviegoer, critic or not, is supposed to do, I believe.
What do you guys think?
As a fan of literature, my studies (which became a hobby) overlap into film. I can't watch a film without looking at the plot, finding the allegory, the metaphors and allusions. Sometimes it can be distracting from enjoying mindless entertainment, but I don't think filmmakers make film to be "just a movie." I think somewhere there is always some type of message, even if that message is just "have fun and enjoy life" or in some slasher films I assume the message must be "be thankful you are still alive."
Usually the message in a slasher film is "if you have sex or do drugs, kiss your a-- goodbye."
I love the slasher film debate, too. People call them mysogynistic and crass and pointless, and they are all of those things I suppose, but they usually don't "hate" women. Women are chiefly the main characters and are almost always the ones who end up defeating the bad guy at the end.